A complaint by the man who spent two years investigating World Cup corruption claims for Fifa has been dismissed by football’s governing body.
US lawyer Michael Garcia’s findings were released as a 42-page summary by Fifa-appointed independent judge Hans-Joachim Eckert.
Garcia said his summary was
and he appealed against it to Fifa’s Appeal Committee.
However, it has now ruled that Garcia’s complaint is “not admissible”.
In a statement, Fifa said German Eckert’s summary was “neither legally binding nor appealable”.
Garcia was appointed by Fifa to lead the investigation into the bidding process for the 2018 and 2022 World Cups in Russia and Qatar following a series of damaging allegations.
A complaint by two whistleblowers who said their confidentiality was compromised after they gave evidence to Garcia’s inquiry has also been dismissed by Fifa.
Phaedra Al Majid and Bonita Mersiades, who worked for the Qatari and Australian bid teams respectively, spoke to Fifa about alleged corruption on condition of anonymity.
when Eckert’s summary of Garcia’s report was released.
But Fifa says there are “no grounds” for opening disciplinary proceedings.
“No names were mentioned in the statement and any information provided was of a general nature,” a Fifa spokesman said.
“Thus, there was no divulgence of any information of a confidential nature.
“The chairman reviewed all provided material and stressed that, since the participants in the investigation had gone public with their own media activities long before the publication of the statement of the chairman of the adjudicatory chamber Judge Eckert, the breach of confidentiality claim had no substance.”
There have been
in the wake of Garcia’s complaint, but Fifa has said it cannot do so for legal reasons.
However, Fifa is meeting in Marrakech, Morocco, this week when it will vote on an amendment to its ethics code that could lead to an edited version of the full report being released.
Speaking before her complaint was dismissed on Tuesday, Al Majid told BBC Radio 5 live sports news correspondent Richard Conway she feared others would be identified if the Fifa proposal to publish an edited version of the report was passed by executives.
“I feel extremely upset and concerned because me and 75 other people were promised that everything would remain confidential,” she said.
“When I asked Michael Garcia if there ever would be a redacted form released I was told ‘no’ and that only four people would ever see the report.”